I have a couple bad pictures of the renderings of the two concepts:
Parking Ramp Rendering - proposed adding stories to the parking ramp for housing.
And the 200 E Mifflin Rendering - proposed tearing down all the houses on the 200 block of E. Mifflin, with perhaps houses on Webster and N Butler as well.
With the parking ramp proposal, its hard to know exactly what it proposed, as this is the second rendering provided, but at least one previous proposal from another developer included demolishing three houses on N Hamilton and I don't recall if there were any more.
With the 200 N Mifflin project, the rendering appears to require the following demolitions:
(Black and white pictures available at and info in the charts from Wisconsin Architecture and History Inventory)
223 E Mifflin – Matthias and Anna Statz House (1897 according to Assessor)
County: DANE | Record #: 75104 | Location: 223 E MIFFLIN ST |
City or Village: MADISON | Town, Range, Section: | Quarter Sections: |
Civil Town: | National Register Date: | State Register Date: |
Unincorporated Community: | District: |
Current Name: Mifflin Street Studios | NR Multiple Property Name: | |
Survey Map: parcel book | Historic Name: Matthias and Anna Statz House | Wall Material: Clapboard |
Map Code: see ac | Construction Date: 1897 | Structural System: |
Survey Date: 1982 | Designer Name: | Other Buildings on Site?: N |
Style or Form: Queen Anne | Cultural Affiliation: |
Resource Type: house | Demolished Date: |
AHI: 75104
Additional Comments:
Map code is 0709-133-3110-7.
Bibliographic References:
City directory. Tax records. Wisconsin State Journal 12/31/1897.
219 E Mifflin (1904 according to assessor)
County: DANE | Record #: 107837 | Location: 219 E MIFFLIN ST |
City or Village: MADISON | Town, Range, Section: | Quarter Sections: |
Civil Town: | National Register Date: | State Register Date: |
Unincorporated Community: | District: |
Current Name: | NR Multiple Property Name: | |
Survey Map: Parcel Book | Historic Name: | Wall Material: Clapboard |
Map Code: See AC | Construction Date: 1892 1898 | Structural System: |
Survey Date: 1983 | Designer Name: | Other Buildings on Site?: N |
Style or Form: Queen Anne | Cultural Affiliation: |
Resource Type: house | Demolished Date: |
AHI: 107837
Additional Comments:
The map code is 0709-133-3111-5.
Bibliographic References:
Sanborn-Perris Maps.
215 E Mifflin (1892 according to the assessor) – no AHI records
(I'm kinda partial to houses with garages like this downtown!)
209 E Mffilin (1899 according to the assessor) – no AHI records
201 E Mifflin (1886 according to the assessor) Winslow O and Jeanette Livermore House
County: DANE | Record #: 28240 | Location: 201 E MIFFLIN ST |
City or Village: MADISON | Town, Range, Section: | Quarter Sections: |
Civil Town: | National Register Date: | State Register Date: |
Unincorporated Community: | District: |
Current Name: | NR Multiple Property Name: | |
Survey Map: parcel book | Historic Name: Livermore, Winslow O. and Jeanette House | Wall Material: Clapboard |
Map Code: see AC | Construction Date: 1887 | Structural System: |
Survey Date: 1982 | Designer Name: | Other Buildings on Site?: N |
Style or Form: Other Vernacular | Cultural Affiliation: |
Resource Type: house | Demolished Date: |
AHI: 28240
Additional Comments:
A 'site file' exists for this property. It contains additional information such as correspondence, newspaper clippings, or historical information. It is a public record and may be viewed in person at the State Historical Society, Division of Historic Preservation. Map code is 0709-133-3114-9.
Bibliographic References:
Historic name: city directory Date of construction: Pt.1 Application
This house along with the 2 on Webster are currently owned by Claire-Mira LLC, Navin Jarugumilli is the registered agent.
19 - 21 N Webster (1904 according to the assessor) Andrew M and Ann Kentzler Residence
County: DANE | Record #: 115704 | Location: 19-21 N WEBSTER ST |
City or Village: MADISON | Town, Range, Section: | Quarter Sections: |
Civil Town: | National Register Date: | State Register Date: |
Unincorporated Community: | District: |
Current Name: | NR Multiple Property Name: | |
Survey Map: Parcel Book | Historic Name: Andrew M. & Anna Kentzler Residence | Wall Material: Clapboard |
Map Code: See AC | Construction Date: 1898 | Structural System: |
Survey Date: 1983 | Designer Name: | Other Buildings on Site?: N |
Style or Form: Queen Anne | Cultural Affiliation: |
Resource Type: house | Demolished Date: |
Bibliographic References:
Tax records; city directories; Sanborn-Perris maps; WSJ, 1-3-1899.
23 - 25 N Webster (1894 according to the assessor) – No AHI records
Other Houses on the block affected by this development, but not proposed for demolition include not only the Lamp House, but the following:
17 N Webster (1872 according to the assessor) August Jonas Residence
| County: DANE | Record #: 115703 | Location: 17 N WEBSTER ST |
| City or Village: MADISON | Town, Range, Section: | Quarter Sections: |
| Civil Town: | National Register Date: | State Register Date: |
| Unincorporated Community: | District: |
| Current Name: | NR Multiple Property Name: | |
| Survey Map: Parcel Book | Historic Name: August Jonas Residence | Wall Material: Brick |
| Map Code: See AC | Construction Date: 1869 | Structural System: |
| Survey Date: 1983 | Designer Name: | Other Buildings on Site?: N |
| Style or Form: Queen Anne | Cultural Affiliation: |
| Resource Type: house | Demolished Date: |
Bibliographic References:
Tax records, 1882-3.
This house is owned by Jamm Management LLC, c/o Steve Moss
15 N Webster (1889 according to the assessor) August Jonas House
| County: DANE | Record #: 99213 | Location: 15 N WEBSTER ST |
| City or Village: MADISON | Town, Range, Section: | Quarter Sections: |
| Civil Town: | National Register Date: | State Register Date: |
| Unincorporated Community: | District: |
| Current Name: | NR Multiple Property Name: | |
| Survey Map: parcel book | Historic Name: August Jonas House | Wall Material: Brick |
| Map Code: see ac | Construction Date: 1890 | Structural System: |
| Survey Date: 1983 | Designer Name: | Other Buildings on Site?: N |
| Style or Form: Queen Anne | Cultural Affiliation: |
| Resource Type: house | Demolished Date: |
18 N Butler (1884 according to the assessor) Samual H Carman and William Lamp Residence
| County: DANE | Record #: 37358 | Location: 18 N BUTLER ST |
| City or Village: MADISON | Town, Range, Section: | Quarter Sections: |
| Civil Town: | National Register Date: | State Register Date: |
| Unincorporated Community: | District: |
| Current Name: | NR Multiple Property Name: | |
| Survey Map: City of Madison Parcel Book | Historic Name: Samuel H. Carman Residence/Robert & William Lamp Resi | Wall Material: Brick |
| Map Code: See AC | Construction Date: 1858 | Structural System: |
| Survey Date: 1985 | Designer Name: | Other Buildings on Site?: |
| Style or Form: Italianate | Cultural Affiliation: |
| Resource Type: duplex | Demolished Date: |
Owned by Jeeves LLC, Erik Minton
24 N Butler (1890 according to the assessor) - No AHI records.
Also owned by Jeeves LLC, Erik Minton
For those of you interested, the grand daddy . . . the Frank Lloyd Wright Lamp House . . .22 N Butler which is not proposed for demolition, but instead would be viewed from the cut out in the building.
I couldn't really take a picture that would do the house justice. Check the link above. Or a more recent/more accurate picture here on flickr.
I couldn't really take a picture that would do the house justice. Check the link above. Or a more recent/more accurate picture here on flickr.
County: DANE | Record #: 16091 | Location: 22 N BUTLER ST |
City or Village: MADISON | Town, Range, Section: | Quarter Sections: |
Civil Town: | National Register Date: 1/3/1978 | State Register Date: 1/1/1989 |
Unincorporated Community: | District: LAMP, ROBERT M., HOUSE |
Current Name: | NR Multiple Property Name: | |
Survey Map: CITY OF MADISON PARCEL BOOK | Historic Name: Robert M. Lamp House | Wall Material: Brick |
Map Code: BRAC | Construction Date: 1903 | Structural System: |
Survey Date: 1978 | Designer Name: FRANK LLOYD WRIGHT | Other Buildings on Site?: |
Style or Form: Prairie School | Cultural Affiliation: |
Resource Type: house | Demolished Date: |
AHI: 16091
Additional Comments:
MAP CODE IS 0709-133-3108-2. EARLY EXAMPLE OF FRANK LLOYD WRIGHT'S WORK, THIS TWO-STORY BRICK HOUSE FEATURES AN OPEN FLOOR PLAN AND WAS BUILT FOR A CHILDHOOD FRIEND OF THE ARCHITECT. IT IS THE OLDEST FLW HOUSE IN MADISON. MADISON LANDMARK 1-28-76.
So, we should learn more tonight. And then create a steering committee to work with Apex. The neighborhood started a website/blog, which will likely be updated as the project progresses.
Nice try Brenda! You are full of it and that's why you lost your election. The fact these homes are owned by Joe Schmoe ain't going to make them either historic nor worth preserving.
ReplyDeleteFrankly, if you want to prevent this development allow me to lease the space in any of these homes and set up a bar and restaurant or a grocery store or a specialty retail store. This entire block is zoned commercial C2 which the idiots at Apex and the city never highlighted. They just want to turn this into a residential district to perpetuity which should be opposed.
You lived down the block and never gave hill of beans about the Lamp House. You lost your election and now you want your job back and this is your forum. Lie about local small landlords who are trying to make it. You would rather see some out of town developer reap the benefits.
Your reasoning is BS and you know it. One more thing the neighborhood, the landmarks, urban design and the PLAN COMMISSION are all advisory. Remember to respect other peoples property so that they can respect yours.
Wish the best with alderman's campaign!
Oh, yes, that would be brilliant electoral strategy. Especially since 2/3 of the people concerned about the project live in Verveer's district and another 10 - 15% are in Rummel's district. Yawn. We're you drunk when you wrote this?
ReplyDeleteI may disagree with Brenda at times(often probably) but your quote below made me disregard everything else you said Jay because it shows you must know little about her views or m.o.
ReplyDelete"Lie about local small landlords who are trying to make it. You would rather see some out of town developer reap the benefits."